After Doug Williams, Russell Wilson was the second black athlete to win a Super Bowl. “For me to be able to go to back-to-back Super Bowls, and win one of them, I think opened up a lot of doors,” he opined. But it seems not everyone agrees with him. When Shannon Sharpe heard Wilson’s statements, he brought up names like Doug Williams, Shack Harris, Joe Gilliam, and Steve McNair. Did they not open any doors?

Well, Wilson’s statements have some more critics. In a thought-provoking episode of ‘The Odd Couple’ on ‘Fox Sports Radio‘, hosts Rob Parker and Chris Broussard explored the legacy of Black quarterbacks. Their discussion brought a nuanced shift in perspective, challenging the notion of who genuinely laid the groundwork for current stars like Patrick Mahomes. “Like before, there weren’t going to have a black quarterback in the game. It had to be some super super-human athlete like Michael Vick. You know, to get a shot or just a straight drop. I mean Doug Williams had a cannon. You know, they just couldn’t deny him, you know, the right to play,” Chris Broussard said. And Rob Parker agreed.

“And obviously you had a Warren Moon but yeah I think that was progress in that obviously Russell Wilson was great but he was a kind of a game manager which was some progress in the perception of black quarterbacks but yeah, I don’t it’s nothing. I don’t think negatively of him. … You don’t think of him as a trailblazer for black quarterbacks.”

via Imago

Thus, they challenged the notion of Wilson’s pioneering status. The hosts fondly recalled the historic Super Bowl, where Williams, who played for the Washington Commanders, not only broke racial barriers but also captured the MVP award. But let’s also not forget Warren Moon. He was the first black quarterback who was inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame. Before the NFL, Moon played in the CFL and is a part of their Hall of Fame. So that makes him the first HOF inductee for both leagues.

Like Williams and Moon, Michael Vick was electrifying. For Vick, just looking at records and numbers might not do justice. His pace-and-space style is something people remember even today. Though he may have not been the best passing QB, he became the face for mobile QBs. However, can we completely sideline Russell Wilson? Yes, his time in the Denver Broncos was disappointing. But as a nine-time Pro Bowler and Super Bowl champion, he has done his part. But what does former NFL player Shannon Sharpe think about Wilson?

Shannon Sharpe doesn’t agree with Russell Wilson!

After Sharpe learned about Russell Wilson’s “opened up a lot of doors” comment, he immediately had his thoughts ready. “So what role did Doug Williams play? The first African-American quarterback to actually get to and win the Super Bowl and win MVP. So what about Shack Harris? What about Joe Gilliam? So what did Marlin Briscoe do? Jack Harry? Steve McNair? They opened no doors? Donovan McNabb, Michael Vick? So they opened no doors. It was you?”

What rubbed Sharpe the wrong way was that Russell Wilson said “I”, as in ‘he’ was responsible for opening doors. He would have preferred if the QB said he was a part of many black QBs opening doors for the current set of black QBs like Patrick Mahomes. However, how correct is this assessment from Shannon Sharpe? Because Russel Wilson did mention Cam Newton, Robert Griffin III, and Colin Kaepernick.

While this debate can go on, did you know 2023 was an important year for black quarterbacks? At Super Bowl LVII, two Black quarterbacks- Patrick Mahomes and Jalen Hurts- lead their respective teams, the Kansas City Chiefs and the Philadelphia Eagles. It was the first time two black starting quarterbacks were seen together at the Super Bowl.